Skip to content
  • Home
  • About|Join
  • Ethics
  • Events
  • Certificates
  • Decolonise calculators
  • Owia Bulletin
  • Journals
  • Mfundo|CPD
  • Fundi | Dictionary
  • Awards
  • Ushahidi
  • DACCS
  • Kuumba
  • AfroMe
  • Submit
  • Exhibitions
  • Consultancy
  • Catalogue
  • Blog
  • Shop
  • Contact us
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Academia AJSW
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
Africa Social Work and Development Network | Mtandao waKazi zaJamii naMaendeleo waAfrica
Africa Social Work & Development Network | Mtandao waKazi zaJamii naMaendeleo waAfrika

Africa Social Work & Development Network | Mtandao waKazi zaJamii naMaendeleo waAfrika

We create, aggregate and disseminate information and resources to facilitate Social Work and Social Development in Africa.

  • ACADEMICS
    • Lecture Resources
    • Lectures
    • Fieldwork Resources
    • Approaches to assessing learning
    • Types of University Assessments
    • ASWDNet Guide to Writing (Journals)
    • ASWDNet Guide to Writing and Publishing
  • PRACTITIONERS
    • Values and Ethics in Africa
    • Africa Social Work and Development Awards
    • Continuous Professional Development (CPD)
    • Templates, Models, Frameworks, Assessment Tools and Questionnaires
    • African Theories
    • Supervision
  • STUDENTS
    • Day of the African Child Conference of Students (DACCS)
    • 12 Steps to Get Published
    • Tips for Prospective Doctoral Students
    • ASWDNet Guide to Writing (Academic Research Brief| Proposal | Thesis)
    • Writing a journal article could be as easy as making fufu, nsima, ugali or matoke!
    • Lectures
    • Glossary of Publishing Terms
  • RESEARCHERS
    • Research Methods
    • Qualitative data levels of analysis
    • African Independent Ethics Committee (AIEC)
    • Research Questions Bank
    • Publisher/Journal Checker
    • Research Strategies
    • Reviewers
    • Ubuntu Research Group (URG)
    • Kuumba (Mentoring)
      • SURVEY OF SOCIAL PROBLEMS AND CHALLENGES FOR AFRICA
      • Mentees
      • Mentors
      • Guidelines
    • Afrocentric Mentoring Project (AfroME)
  • ASSOCIATIONS
  • TRAINING INSTITUTIONS
  • COMMUNITIES
    • Ubuntu Fundraising and Charity Principles
    • COVID-19
    • Social Work for Children
    • Funda KiSwahili
  • MEMBERS
  • African Philosophy
  • African Theories
  • Research Methods
  • Library | Databases
  • Social Work
    • Social Work Education institutions (SWEI) in Africa
    • Biography of Social Development in Africa
      • Charlotte Makgomo-Mannya Maxeke (1871-1939)
      • Zahia Marzouk (1906 – 1988)
      • Regina Gelana Twala (1908-1968)
      • Mai Musodzi Chibhaga Ayema (1885-1952)
      • Nnoseng Ellen Kate Kuzwayo (1914 – 2006)
      • Joshua Mqabuko Nyongolo Nkomo (19 June 1917 – 1 July 1999)
      • Jairos Jiri (1921 – 1982)
      • Kenneth Buchizya Kaunda (1924-2021)
      • John Samuel Mbiti (1931-2019)
      • Gibson Mthuthuzeli Kent (1932-2004)
      • Winnie Madikizela-Mandela 1936–2016
      • Ngugi wa Mirii (1951 – May 3, 2008)
      • Andrew Chad Nyanguru (28 Mar 1953-14 May 2014)
      • Professor Rodreck Mupedziswa
      • Edwell Kaseke (1954-2017)
      • Lovemore Mbigi
      • Selassie Seyoum Gebre (1936-)
      • Arega Yimam (-c1989)
      • Dr Noel Garikai Muridzo
      • Dr Edmos Mthethwa
      • Phillip Manyanye Bohwasi
      • Wassie Kebede
      • Gidraph G Wairire
      • Wangari Muta Maathai
      • Uzoma Odera Okoye, Dr
    • Social Work Journals and Other Serial Publications in Africa (ASWDNet Index)
    • Association of Social Work Education in Africa (ASWEA) – 1965 to 1989
    • Future of Social Work in Africa
    • Environmental Social Work
  • Development
  • Ubuntu
    • Ubuntu Research Group (URG)
    • Ushahidi Platform
    • Ubuntu Fundraising and Charity Principles
    • Ubuntu Bibliography
    • Ubuntu Survey
    • Ubuntu Annual Lecture
    • Ubuntu Interview Guide Sample
  • Africa
    • African Anthem (African Union)
    • Umoja waAfrica (African Union)
    • African symbols and alphabets
    • Fundi – The African Dictionary and Encyclopaedia of Social Work and Development
    • Africa Religion (uAfrica)
    • Africa Research Ethics and Malpractice Statement (AREMS)
    • The San Code of Research Ethics (San Code)
  • Blog
    • Our Ubuntu-inspired Comments Policy
    • Become a Blogger
  • Mfundo | CPD
    • Courses
      • Mental Health Masterclass - Friendship Bench
      • Ubuntu Basics Course
      • Research Ethics Course (REC)
      • Peer Reviewers Course (Hwe Mu Dua)
    • Profile
    • How to do Mfundo courses
    • Mfundo Terms and Conditions

How journal metrics and rankings deceive African writers, publishers, readers and universities

Posted on 4 April 20223 September 2022 By aswnetadmin

In recent years, several online based measurements of publications and research quality have emerged. Most (if not all) of these metrics and rankings were designed in developed countries and they are linked to powerful publishers or institutions. These measurements, called metrics or rankings, have been criticised for disadvantaging researchers, writers and publishers from developing countries who have said metrics and rankings are exaggerated and given too much importance. Others have looked at them as colonial projects whose intentions are to keep other publishers on the periphery while others have looked at them as offering a pathway to quality research.  This article will highlight what those who have criticised these metrics have said and offer some solutions for Africa.

  1. Metrics and rankings are biased and not just. They are based on the internet whereas Africa has less internet penetration. They are based on historical data e.g. prestige of a journal yet Africa was colonised for a long period during which its publications were in European or American publications.
  2. They promote dissemination of findings to international not local audiences, making research less useful for communities and countries where people research.
  3. High ranked journals require payments, as high as USD5000, money which all writers and universities in developing countries won’t afford.
  4. Most publications are in English language which on its own is a huge barrier to developing countries. Production of literature in local language will not happen where English is the norm.
  5. In other countries, e.g. South Africa, researchers receive an incentive for publishing. However, if a journal is not listed in an international index, mainly SCOPUS, you will not get the incentive. This disadvantages African publishers and force them to seek accreditation with the international indexing companies. Further, African journals will have less submissions as academics take their research to high ranking international journals.
  6. Achieving high rank status comes at a cost, including but not limited to cost of running an independent journal website, cost of hiring a journal management system and many other costs such as DOI etc.
  7. The definition for impact used by those who rank and index publications is questionable. If a published paper is read several times in Europe and not in Africa, does it make it high impact? If an article is published in a non-indexed journal and is read several times in Africa, isn’t that stronger impact?
  8. Most of the so called high impact journals are not even global, they are national or regional, they promote interests and values of the countries or regions. A journal article accepted in Europe or America will carry their values otherwise it will not get published.
  9. African libraries are impacted too, they end up ordering so called high impact journals and books that do not address local issues. This happens because publishers and writers of ‘less impact work’ are not found in databases the librarians search for books and journals.
  10. Digital Object Identifiers (DOI) are advertised as permanent identifiers but they are not.  They are advertised as free but they are not. It is thought that they increase visibility or discoverability but this only happens outside Africa. While permanent identification is important if achieved, the problem is that it neglects crucial issues like open access, print access and it increases the workload of editors and publishers, pushing the cost of publishing and publications up. In sad cases, the requirement to use applications such as DOI as a mark of quality results in another journals dying.

What are possible solutions?

Solutions include African universities using local databases to determine quality of publications. An example is the African Journals Online which has a ranking system. Universities or countries can also create their own ranking systems. Africa needs more publishers, including university presses, government and independent publishers. More importantly, African  researchers and writers need to cite African research. If African research is not cited, it will not grow. Librarians play an important role in making available literature to read, it is natural, therefore that librarians should decolonise the library – order African literature, decommission colonial literature and promote growth of African literature. lastly, the impact of African research must not be measured solely by standards developed in developed and more developed countries, our impact should be measured by how much our research is changing lives, addressing problems, impacting governments and is relevant to local situations.

What to read more?

Nkomo, S. M. (2009). The Seductive Power of Academic Journal Rankings: Challenges of Searching for the Otherwise. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 8(1), 106–112.

Mugumbate, J., and Mtetwa, E. (2019). Reframing social work research for Africa’s consumers of research products: a guiding tool. African Journal of Social Work, 9(2), 52-58. https://www.ajol.info/index.php/ajsw/article/view/192200

Admin ASWDNet

Post navigation

Previous Post: IS A DEFINITIONAL THRESHOLD OF 18 YEARS FOR WHO A CHILD IS, PRACTICALLY APPLICABLE AND FEASIBLE?
Next Post: AFRICA’ CONTINENTAL ANTHEM BY THE AFRICAN UNION (AU): ITS SIGNIFICANCE IN SOCIAL WORK

AFRICA-WIDE INSTITUTIONS

ASWEA logo

ASWEA

1971-1989

Umoja waAfrika (AU) Former OAU Toto/Brief | Agenda63

ADF

Part of ADB

ASSWA logo

ASSWA

Since 2005

PAWO (AU Arm)

Facebook | X

COUNTRY INFORMATION

  • Algeria 🇩🇿
  • Angola 🇦🇴
  • Benin 🇧🇯
  • Botswana 🇧🇼
  • Burkina Faso 🇧🇫
  • Burundi 🇧🇮
  • Cabo Verde 🇨🇻
  • Cameroon 🇨🇲
  • Central African Republic 🇨🇫
  • Chad 🇹🇩
  • Comoros 🇰🇲
    • Mayotte of Comoro
  • Congo, DR 🇨🇩
  • Congo 🇨🇬
  • Cote D’Ivoire 🇨🇮
  • Djibouti 🇩🇯
  • Egypt 🇪🇬
  • Equatorial Guinea 🇬🇶
  • Eritrea 🇪🇷
  • Eswatini 🇸🇿
  • Ethiopia 🇪🇹
  • Gabon 🇬🇦
  • Gambia, The 🇬🇲
  • Ghana 🇬🇭
  • Guinea 🇬🇳
  • Guinea-Bissau 🇬🇼
  • Kenya 🇰🇪
  • Lesotho 🇱🇸
  • Liberia 🇱🇷
  • Libya 🇱🇾
  • Madagascar 🇲🇬
  • Malawi 🇲🇼
  • Mali 🇲🇱
  • Mauritania 🇲🇷
  • Mauritius 🇲🇺
  • Morocco 🇲🇦
  • Mozambique 🇲🇿
  • Namibia 🇳🇦
  • Niger 🇳🇪
  • Nigeria 🇳🇬
  • Rwanda 🇷🇼
  • Sao Tome and Principe 🇸🇹
  • Senegal 🇸🇳
  • Seychelles 🇸🇨
  • Sierra Leone 🇸🇱
  • Somalia 🇸🇴
  • South Africa 🇿🇦
  • South Sudan 🇸🇸
  • Sudan 🇸🇩
  • Togo 🇹🇬
  • Tanzania 🇹🇿
  • Tunisia 🇹🇳
  • Uganda 🇺🇬
  • Western Sahara (SADR)
  • Zambia 🇿🇲
  • Zimbabwe 🇿🇼
  • “Dongo”
  • ‘Wakanda’
  • Umoja waAfrica (African Union)
  • Afro-Caribbeans
    • Haiti
  • Afro-Latinos
  • Melanesia
    • Aboriginal Countries
    • Papua New Guinea
    • West Papua
  • Afro-Asians ‘Sidi’

Decolonisation Calculator (DECA). What is the rate of decolonisation of social work and development training, education and research in your country? Use this simple calculator.

COVID-19 FINAL UPDATE: Africa Infections: 12.3 million people. Deaths 260 000. World infections: 650 million. Deaths 6.7 million. Data aggregated by ASWDNet on 12 December 2022. View this COVID-19 references list for Africa.

Search

Policies | Protocols | Guidelines | Checklists

  • Ubuntu Acknowledgements
  • AI Policy
  • San Code of Ethics
  • Journal Writing Guide
  • Ubuntu Principles in Fundraising & Charity
  • Comments Policy
  • Publisher Checker
  • Decolonisation Calculator
  • African Research Ethics & Malpractice Statement
  • Privacy & Cookie Policy
  • Email, Data and Social Media Policy
  • Comments Policy

Recent Posts

  • Nommo: an African relational research method that values griots (human libraries), speech and narratives
  • Artificial Intelligence for Ubuntu Studies (AI4US): a ScienceOpen collection
  • How to decolonise your use of Claude.AI?
  • China’s Society Work and the decolonisation of Social Work: Meaning, reasons and implications for Africa
  • Joint African Conference of IFSW & ASSWA in Malawi (2027): How Mtandao members can take part

Email Sign In


Website Log In


Mfundo | Courses | CPD Log In


Members Portal

COPYRIGHT © 2020 to 2030: Mtandao - Africa Social Work and Development Network (ASWDNet) | UBUNTU ACKNOWLEDGEMENT - We pay our respects to those who came before us, our Elders and forefathers and mothers, who are the sources and protectors (against colonisation) of the knowledge and wisdom that continue to shape lives, teaching, learning, research, and practice across generations. Because they were, we are. Asante. Siyabonga. Tatenda. Waaw. Àṣé. INDIGENISATION STATEMENT - Mtandao is a pan-African network grounded in Ubuntu. We recognise the sovereignty, knowledge systems and cultural protocols of African and Indigenous peoples, and we use these knowledges as primary frameworks in our publishing, teaching and research.